The Theory of Persistence
Théorème

Lemma G — Hilbert reconstruction

The reconstructed QFT's Hilbert space is $\mathcal{H}_\infty = \varinjlim \bigotimes_{p \mid m_K} \mathcal{H}_p$.

Statement

The Hilbert space of the QFT reconstructed (by Osterwalder–Schrader, cf. Lemmas E and F) is:

H=limKpmKHp,\boxed{\mathcal{H}_\infty = \varinjlim_{K \to \infty} \bigotimes_{p \,\mid\, m_K} \mathcal{H}_p,}

the inductive limit of the per-CRT-factor tensor products, where each Hp\mathcal{H}_p is the finite-dimensional Hilbert space associated with the mod-pp sieve.

Théorème

Plain reading. The state space of quantum mechanics (the “Hilbert space”) is not arbitrarily posited in PT. It is constructed as a particular combination of small spaces, one per active prime, assembled by tensor product. No hidden representation choice.

Why it matters

Lemma G completes the (E, F, G) reconstruction triad:

With these three lemmas, the QFT reconstructed from the sieve is completely characterised: observable algebra (A\mathcal{A}), metric (by F), Hilbert space (by G), and coupling (by E). No external element added.

This justifies saying PT “reconstructs physics” rather than “identifies the sieve with physics”.

Proof — outline

  1. Step G.1: for each prime pp, the space Hp\mathcal{H}_p is the finite-dim Hilbert space associated with the transfer TpT_p.
  2. Step G.2: the CRT decomposition gives Hm=pmHp\mathcal{H}_m = \bigotimes_{p \mid m} \mathcal{H}_p for every modulus mm.
  3. Step G.3: the inductive limit lim\varinjlim exists and is well-defined by OS compatibility.

Detailed proof

Step G.1 — Per-prime Hilbert space

For each prime pp, the Hilbert space Hp\mathcal{H}_p associated with the transfer TpT_p has dimension p1p - 1 (number of non-zero residue classes mod pp after eliminating 0). Finite-dimensional, equipped with the inner product defined by TpT_p‘s stationary measure.

For active primes {3,5,7}\{3, 5, 7\}: dimH3=2\dim \mathcal{H}_3 = 2, dimH5=4\dim \mathcal{H}_5 = 4, dimH7=6\dim \mathcal{H}_7 = 6.

Step G.2 — Tensor CRT decomposition

By CRT, for m=p1p2pkm = p_1 p_2 \cdots p_k a product of distinct primes:

Hm=pmHp.\mathcal{H}_m = \bigotimes_{p \mid m} \mathcal{H}_p.

This is the isomorphism between the Hilbert space on Z/mZ\mathbb{Z}/m\mathbb{Z} and the tensor product over prime factors. Consistent with the tensor factorisation of the transfer matrix Tm=pTpT_m = \bigotimes_p T_p.

For the arithmetic torus T3=Z/105Z\mathbb{T}^3 = \mathbb{Z}/105\mathbb{Z} (with 105=357105 = 3 \cdot 5 \cdot 7):

H105=H3H5H7,\mathcal{H}_{105} = \mathcal{H}_3 \otimes \mathcal{H}_5 \otimes \mathcal{H}_7,

of dimension 246=482 \cdot 4 \cdot 6 = 48.

Step G.3 — Inductive limit

The family {mK}K1\{m_K\}_{K \geq 1} with mK+1=mKpK+1m_{K+1} = m_K \cdot p_{K+1} (adding a new prime at each step) generates an increasing chain of spaces Hm1Hm2\mathcal{H}_{m_1} \hookrightarrow \mathcal{H}_{m_2} \hookrightarrow \cdots.

The inductive limit:

H=limKHmK\mathcal{H}_\infty = \varinjlim_{K \to \infty} \mathcal{H}_{m_K}

exists in the sense of pre-Hilbert spaces. The completion gives a separable infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, which is exactly the OS-reconstructed QFT state space.

Compatibility with OS axioms

The inclusions HmKHmK+1\mathcal{H}_{m_K} \hookrightarrow \mathcal{H}_{m_{K+1}} are isometric (preserve inner product) because the transfers TpT_p are stochastic. This ensures the limit is well-defined and the observable algebra A\mathcal{A} extends continuously.

Structural implications

  • Per-prime finite dimensionality: each factor remains finite-dimensional, making explicit computations possible.
  • Separable limit: H\mathcal{H}_\infty has a countable basis, consistent with standard quantum mechanics axioms.
  • CRT-factorisable: any operator on H\mathcal{H}_\infty decomposes over prime factors — the technical foundation of Pontryagin (BA5).

For the complete derivation, see chapter 9 of the monograph, section Hilbert Reconstruction (Lemma G).

See also